Williamsburg, NY – Court Rejects Challenge By Hasidic Jews Requesting Housing Accommodation Near Religious Facilities

    13

    Williamsburg, NY – A New York federal district court rejected challenges by a group of Hasidic Jews to the New York City Housing Authority’s Tenant Selection Assignment Plan as it operates to allocate access to public housing units in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    In Ungar v. New York City Housing Authority, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 3578, Plaintiffs particularly concerned about access to apartments to accommodate large families, claim that they have religious needs to live near various religious facilities and other members of their religious community in Williamsburg.

    The court rejected plaintiffs’ argument that receipt of federal funding made the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act applicable to the city housing agency. It also rejected plaintiffs’ federal Fair Housing Act claim that the failure to provide applicants for public housing with the option to designate three Williamsburg projects has a disparate impact on the Hasidic community.
    Finally the court rejected plaintiffs’ free exercise claim, holding that “the Authority’s admission and transfer policies do not bar any particular religious practice or interfere in any way with the free exercise of religion by singling out a particular religion or imposing any disabilities on the basis of religion.”

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group
    13 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    17 years ago

    Hey, if you wanna be on the dole, you should’nt have any right on where you want to be… talk about chutzpah!

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    17 years ago

    While they should have the same rights to public housing as any other party, they should have absoluty no preferences over goyim or other yidden so that ehy can live near their shul or beth medrash so they don’t have a long walk or get a larger apartment because they insist on having many kids…Don’t seek special accomodations which disadvantage others. If it can be done with discrimination, then by all means it should be done.

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    17 years ago

    Apt size in Public housing is based on family size. Most people don’t choose it, but it is nice that it is there for those who need it. You should hope and pray that you never do, but when there are difficult circumstances, it is good that it is there. My husband became disabled due to illness after the birth of our 6th child. A lot of people asked me, did I wish I did not have so many children. The answer was NO!! It was my children that kept me going. Every child is a bracha and it is a very goyishe mentality to say that only rich people should have children. This is what Rabbi Papo ztl warned about living in a Christian country, that we would assimilate to their ways and stop valuing a large family. In the Muslim countries they value a large family and that IS a man’s wealth.

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    17 years ago

    i am so embarrassed that this even went to court.

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    17 years ago

    Well its very nice that this yigeleit that have housing in the city projacts are try to fight for other fellow jews, And for a giy its no differant where he gets an apt. So why should jewish peopole make Such bad Comments about erlicha Askunim

    Yoshua
    Yoshua
    17 years ago

    I thought that NYCHA was supposed to supply “public housing” that is housing for the public. The residents of Williamsburg will not live in public housing that is not near their community. Where will they daven, what will they eat or buy food, were will they send their kids to school? Why would we want our poor and vulnerable yidden to live in projects near no other yidden?
    All NYCHA is doing is excusing itself from supplying public housing for this population. If you are poor you have no dignity that the State is supposed to uphold? Just because you are unfortunate enough to receive public assistance does not mean that the State should be able to dictate exactly all the terms and conditions of your assistance. If only we gave these Walll St welfare recipients as hard a time we would all be in a better place.
    Subjecting and embracing the poor, these are not Jewish values, what happened to the medina shel chessed? I hope this gets overturned, G-d wiling.
    Shavua Tov klal Yisrael!

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    17 years ago

    Reply to #9 Hashem Asked us to have as much children as possible he created the world to be full And He makes All Cheshboynoys not us, Each and every child being Born is Hashems doing and if he gets us children he give us housing and food we might have to struggle as you can see the rich lost so much what do think they knew the cheshben One cheshben we have is we have is Cheshbon hanefesh and to do good to every one and to melamed zechis on Every one
    Hashem should have Rachmunes on all if us

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    17 years ago

    if you are getting something from the government, dont go and make a court case out of it. if you get something for free would you go and complain? i think that this is a big chillul hashem. appreciate whatever the city is giving you, and it wont hurt if you walk a few blocks to shul!!!!

    anonymous
    anonymous
    16 years ago

    large families are a beautiful thing BUT having children comes with many responsibilities including the financial responsibility. I came from a large family. I have over 90 first cousins. I would love to have more than one child, but I chose to live in New York and cannot afford to have more than one child. I don’t understand why someone would think it just to have more children than they can afford and let society pay the bill. There are people who are truly disabled or having hard times that need financial assistance; having more children than you afford is not something to be rewarded.