New York – Poskim Advisory: Rulings Regarding Shabbos Observance And The Impending Hurricane


    Heavy rains and wind from Hurricane Irene whip the sand on the beach at Pawleys Island, S.C., Friday, Aug. 26, 2011. Hurricane Irene began lashing the East Coast with rain Friday ahead of a weekend of violent weather that was almost certain to heap punishment on a vast stretch of shoreline from the Carolinas to Massachusetts. (AP Photo/Bruce Smith)These rulings were approved by both Rabbi Dovid Weinberger Shlita Posaik on behalf of Hatzolah of Hatzolah of Far Rockaway/Five Towns, and Rabbi Shmuel Fuerst Dayan of Chicago, a renowned Posaik.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email

    1] Anyone who is concerned of a danger may and should leave the radio on over Shabbos. Ideally the volume control should be taped. It should also be placed in a room that is generally not used – so that you can access information readily. If the situation requires that the volume control should be raised, an attempt to raise it with a shinui should be made. Otherwise it may be raised normally.

    2] If the radio says that the storm is definitely or most likely approaching and a situation of pikuach Nefesh will exist, then one may make preparations to leave on Shabbos if it is estimated that leaving Motzei Shabbos will not leave one with sufficient time to avoid being stuck.

    3] Everyone remaining in a potential mandatory evacuation zone should prepare from before Shabbos to leave on Motzei Shabbos immediately.

    4] In the event that one must evacuate on Shabbos – ideally one should have a gentile drive the car or one should call a cab. When one reached safety one may not shut the car off – one should request a gentile to do so. If there will be a further need to evacuate and one needs to spare gasoline then one may shut it off.

    5] If one is evacuating on Shabbos – one may not carry items other than what is needed for Shabbos, food for a baby even for beyond Shabbos, and medications that are of a potential life threatening nature (heart medication eg.)

    The reason for the urgency is that the evacuation routes are limited because of flooding of the highways and the closing down of bridges. Leaving on Motzei Shabbos may not give people sufficient time to escape. The Mayor has issued evacuation orders from many low lying areas and much of the Rockaways [Area A and Area B]. It is therefore advisable for anyone who can to evacuate before Shabbos to either the Flushing area of Queens, Brooklyn,

    The author can be reached at [email protected]

    Below From Agudath Israel – Halachic Guidelines for Hurricanes:

    The following is reprinted from the Halacha Hurricane Manual published by Agudath Israel of Florida, based on questions asked to Rabbi Moshe Heinemann, Rav Agudas Yisroel of Baltimore.

    1. In case of an impending hurricane predicted to hit on Shabbos, may one leave the radio on?
    Yes, leave the radio on in a private area on a low volume.

    2. If told to evacuate, what should one do?
    One must always do whatever is necessary to protect one’s life. Therefore one is allowed to drive to a secure place and take along whatever is necessary, even money. Once one is out of harms way, he should stay put until after Shabbos. If a child or elderly person is present and staying in the car would be a danger, one can proceed to a shelter. One may also put gas in the car if needed to arrive at a safe place.

    3. If one stays home, may the shutters be placed on the windows?
    There are two popular types of shutters: accordion and panel. Accordion shutters are permanently attached to the home and may be closed. Panel shutters need to be installed with each use and may only be placed on the windows if the situation is one where life is in danger-not to protect property.

    4. If instructed to bring indoors all loose furniture and garden equipment, is one allowed to?
    One is permitted to bring indoors whatever might pose a danger.

    5. If someone sees a power line fall and it poses a danger can one contact the authorities?
    A person should never venture out during or right after a hurricane. Coming in contact with downed power lines could be fatal. Unless the power line could cause a serious danger to the people in the home, one should wait until after Shabbos to report it.

    6. Does the category of the hurricane make a difference?
    The different categories represent the intensity of the hurricane winds and the danger they pose. But the authorities can determine that even a category one or two hurricane poses enough of a threat to certain areas to demand an evacuation. In such cases, all necessary precautions should be taken.

    7. If someone lives alone and needs assistance to evacuate, may one drive there to pick the person up and bring him or her to safety?
    One is allowed to do what is necessary to protect one’s own life or the life of someone else in danger.

    8. At what wind velocity should the eruv not be assumed to be kosher?
    Once the winds reach the speed of 35 mph, one should assume the eruv is not kosher and should not carry outside.

    9. If the electricity went out and was then turned back on, may one eat the food that was on the blech or hot-plate?
    If the food was fully cooked (or even 1/3 cooked) and is still hot, one may consume the food. Otherwise, one should consult a Rav.

    List of essential items: batteries, flashlights, candles, yartzheit candles, canned food, bottled water- 1 gallon per day per person, battery powered radio, important documents sealed in a water proof bag, insurance information, photographs of household valuables.

    Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

    iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates

    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    Noble Member
    12 years ago

    Thank you for all of this, but when did Rav Weinberger become the Posaik of the Five Towns? There are many other Rabbonim in the 5T who would be interested in knowing this.

    12 years ago

    reply to #1 . it says he is the posek of hatzola of 5t, not the posek of 5t.

    12 years ago

    I hope everybody understands we are talking about battery-operated radios so that if/when the power goes down, you have a radio to listen to for instructions.

    12 years ago

    Where were these LI rabbis when it came to standing up against gay marriage. Now Has-hem is giving us the results.

    Rabbi Yair Hoffman
    12 years ago

    Actually #5 they did speak and write about it. Youcan google them and see what they did. you owe them an apology. a 5 towns resident

    12 years ago

    I love you New Yorkers. A hurricane is on its way and you’re arguing about שטויות.