Jerusalem – Israel Defends Trump Amid Synagogue Shooting Criticism

    25

    President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump put down stones from the White House and flowers at a memorial outside for those killed at the Pittsburgh's Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh, Tuesday, Oct. 30, 2018. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)Jerusalem – With President Donald Trump getting a cool welcome from the Jewish community in Pittsburgh, Israel’s envoy to the memorial ceremonies for the synagogue shooting victims has come to his defense, saying it was “unfair and wrong” to link him to the tragedy.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    Trump was greeted by hundreds of chanting protesters Tuesday, many accusing the president’s fiery rhetoric for contributing to the climate of violence and emboldening extremists to act.

    Pennsylvania’s governor and the mayor of Pittsburgh declined to join Trump during the visit, and one of the families of the 11 victims of the deadliest anti-Semitic attack in U.S. history asked not to meet him. Adding to the anger was the shooting suspect’s apparent targeting of a synagogue because of his outrage over a Jewish refugee agency that has become a target of conspiracy theories among Trump’s nationalist base.

    However, Naftali Bennett, the Israeli minister for diaspora affairs, took issue with those he said were “using this horrific anti-Semitic act to attack President Trump.”

    “This is unfair and wrong,” said Bennett, who rushed to Pittsburgh after the shootings to offer Israel’s support to city’s Jewish community. “President Trump is a true friend of the State of Israel and to the Jewish people. With President Trump we never have to worry if he has our backs.”

    Israel’s envoys to the United States and the United Nations have also tried to distance Trump from the attack.

    Their defense of the president has added another element to the growing divide between Israel’s leadership, which hails Trump for his staunch political backing and tough stance against nemesis Iran, and the more liberal American Jewish community, whose members are among Trump’s toughest domestic critics.

    Trump visited the Tree of Life synagogue and lit candles for the victims before visiting survivors in the hospital. He was accompanied by his daughter Ivanka, a convert to Judaism, and her Jewish husband, Jared Kushner, as well as Israeli Ambassador Ron Dermer.

    Dermer also backed Trump, saying he was “not aware of a single non-Israeli leader that has made such a strong statement in condemning anti-Semitism.”

    Nancy Bernstein, co-chair of J Street Pittsburgh, a liberal American Jewish group, said that many American Jews accuse Trump of contributing to the polarized atmosphere that led to the shooting and were unhappy about Israeli leaders being so close with the president. She took particular aim at Bennett, who has been a visible presence in Pittsburgh after the shooting attack.

    “He has a history of inciting against refugees in Israel, and this was the very reason that 11 people were murdered in our synagogue here,” she said, referring to the alleged shooter’s anger toward a Jewish group that assists immigrants in the U.S.

    “As Jews, we were once refugees and immigrants,” she added. “We understand what it’s like to be turned away and not taken care of. Most of us get it.”

    The Israeli government’s consistent support for Trump has far less to do with his controversial domestic policies and more with the blanket international support he has granted Israel.

    Fulfilling a campaign promise, Trump recognized Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and moved the U.S. Embassy there.

    In a break from previous administrations, he has placed the blame for failed peace talks solely on the Palestinians and refrained from criticizing Israeli settlement activity. He also pulled out of the Iran nuclear agreement, a step welcomed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

    Netanyahu has also angered the liberal Reform and Conservative streams of Judaism, which represent the majority of affiliated Jews in the U.S., by siding with Orthodox rabbinical authorities on issues of recognition and pluralism in Israel.

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group
    25 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    yamsar
    yamsar
    7 years ago

    Birds of a feather flock together! The right wing nationalist in the WH and the alt-right nationalist in Israel are now covering for each other’s policies. In their quest to preserve national identity they agitate against immigrants and Muslims. Stiff speaking Netanyahu should start a reality show with trumpf. What will the name be? Shtuppy and Shtippy?

    PureSatmar
    PureSatmar
    7 years ago

    But not in the name of Judaism, which they have little affiliation with.

    AmYisroel
    AmYisroel
    7 years ago

    leftist are scum who are ant Israel and anti frum

    7 years ago

    Its unfortunate that an american president got sucha welcome from people in Pittsburgh and especiallyJews when going to a non political event.
    Very unfortunate not to put politics behind u and stand to welcome out president with all the respect as the Torah teaches us.
    But what is also unfortunate is that the Israelis have a say in our country. Bennet shldnt speak in our name. He shldnt come lecture anyone here for any reason. Its the State of israel that breeds and feeds antisemitism. Hes not a Diaspora minister. We never voted for him and let him keep Israeli politics out of this. Dont remmber ever electing any Israeli official to represent me or my friends in any way.
    We are Anerican Jews and have no dual loyalty’s to Israel.

    7 years ago

    We dont need Israel to defend Trump. If AmericanJewish people dont understand the simple act of respect for a sitting president then we have a lot left desired for. But Israel is not our lawyer. Stay out and stay away! We never asked u to represent us on any way. Not Bennet nor his colleagues.

    DanielBarbaz
    DanielBarbaz
    7 years ago

    The constant name calling and disrespect for others with an opinion different from their own is immature and disgusting and does not befit a so-called religious web site. Unbelievable that anyone who considers themselves Frum would conduct themselves this way.

    Do the Gedoilim approve of this? Are we machmir only for “ben adam le-makom” and disregard the Mitzvos of “ben adam le-chaveiro”? Have we learned nothing from 2000 years of Galus?

    7 years ago

    Fake news attempting to represent the entire Jewish community as being anti Trump. Really? And they accuse Trump of using this tragedy for political gain!

    7 years ago

    To #9 - Are you implying that the Jews in Pittsburgh, who are not frum, and don’t belong to Chabad or an Orthodox Shul are not Jews? When Hitler (Y’mach Shimo Levracha), and his henchmen came for the Jews, they didn’t inquire as to their Yiddishkeit, or how observant they were. They could have cared less. It burns me up,that there are still some reactionary individuals on this site, who dismiss the victims of the Pittsburgh massacre and their fellow congregants as “not true Torah Jews”. Similarly, there are rabbinical officials in EY, who also issued proclamations questioning the Jewishness of the victims, and survivors. Last, why did Ron Dermer (who renounced his American citizenship), have to stick his nose in where it didn’t belong, and attend the visit with Trump? While I appreciate Trumps’s visit, I wish to state that Ron Dermer does not represent me, and had no business being with Trump.

    fat36
    fat36
    7 years ago

    If there was a representative from Israel there that is nice to show that when 1 Jew hurts Jews around the world hurt but I don’t think Israel has to defend of what Trump does