ISRAEL – (JTA) — Israeli voters delivered an inconclusive result in last week’s election. More than a week after the vote, it’s still unclear what shape Israel’s government will take.
Join our WhatsApp groupSubscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
But a majority of Jewish voters is clear on one thing: They want their next government to be less religious than it is now.
A new survey by Hiddush, an Israeli organization that supports religious pluralism, shows that 57 percent of the Jewish Israeli electorate does not want the incoming governing coalition to include or depend on parties that are haredi Orthodox, commonly referred to as ultra-Orthodox in the United States. That 57 percent majority also wants the coalition to support religious freedom in Israel.
Thirty-four percent of Israeli Jews disagree: They want the Orthodox parties in the coalition and are happy with current government policy, which gives Orthodox Judaism significant influence over Israeli law. Haredi parties have been part of the Israeli government since 2015 and have sat in a series of coalitions throughout Israel’s history.
The survey’s finding is significant because some of the harshest rhetoric ahead of the election centered on religious issues. Secular parties accused Orthodox parties of wanting to establish a theocracy in Israel. Orthodox parties claimed that secular parties wanted to deprive Israel of its religious character. The only reason for the election last week — Israel’s second in a year — was an intractable conflict between Orthodox and secular parties after the previous election in April.
Nearly all of those who voted for Blue and White, the centrist party led by Benny Gantz and Yair Lapid opposing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, want a secular governing coalition. Most voters for Netanyahu’s Likud Party (56 percent) support a coalition with Orthodox parties, while 44 percent favor a secular coalition.
Sixty-nine percent of respondents also said that support for religious freedom was a significant factor in their vote last week. The survey was taken on September 22 and included 600 Jewish Israeli respondents. The margin of error was 4 percent.
“The elections have unfolded in a way that so clearly points to the concern that Israelis feel with the unholy alliance of religion and state,” said Rabbi Uri Regev, Hiddush’s founder. “The more haredi political leaders felt triumphant, the more they felt they could cash in on their political fortunes, the more Israelis became frustrated and ready to push back.”
The survey follows an annual one by Hiddush on religion in Israel. That survey, like past ones, shows that a solid majority of Israeli Jews wants government policy to be far less influenced by Orthodox law than it is now.
- 64 percent of respondents want there to be separation of religion and state in Israel.
- 68 percent want Israel to recognize civil marriages. At present, Israel only recognizes Orthodox Jewish marriages.
- 64 percent do not want any religious body to have governmental authority in Israel. At present, Israel’s Orthodox Chief Rabbinate controls marriage, divorce, burial and other affairs in Israel.
- 62 percent want Israel to recognize a range of Jewish conversion ceremonies — not just Orthodox ones.
The survey found that, similar to previous years, half of Israeli Jews identify as secular, 31 percent as traditional, 11 percent as Modern Orthodox and 10 percent as haredi Orthodox. The survey also found that 6 percent of Israeli Jews self-identify as Conservative and 7 percent as Reform — though Israelis don’t typically use those terms to define their religious practice.
Politically, 45 percent of Israeli Jews are right-wing and 19 percent are right-leaning. Twenty percent are centrist and 16 percent are left-wing or left-leaning.
The annual survey was taken from August 6 to 11, and included 753 Jewish Israeli adult respondents. The margin of error was 3.6 percent.
A little separation of shul and state might not be such a bad idea.
The Orthodox communities in the USA seem to be doing just fine without government-enforced religious coercion.
Poll results often depend on the poll takers spin.
Those results may be true, but would be interesting if corroborated by other polls.
The thought of a Halachic state frightens people. They picture moving backwards in terms of civil rights, women’s rights and freedoms, like a state with laws as described in the Gemorrah.
Hiddush, an Israeli organization that supports religious pluralism, – pretty biased group, I must point out.
Like the Reform movement publishing a survey saying 52% of charadim want to include gay marriages in the yeshiva beis medresh. I doubt the findings of this biased group.
Putting aside the obvious biases of the group making the survey, what would you expect?
Had the question been about any party the majority of Israelis did not vote for (which is all parties) there would have been a similar response.
It’s like saying that the overwhelming majority of Democrats do not want a conservative appointed to the Supreme Court
A little shocking cuz would suit the atheistic government if Orthodox Jews were part of them. But orthodox People shld know better than join a trifene Medinah. But they dont.
Well, you sort of have to decide. Do you want a religious state or a democratic one?
The reason that Israeli government tolerates the extremists in very religious neighborhoods (who throw rocks at cars, and pedestrians, beat the IDF and stone them, and assault and curse women on buses), is because they have a lot of political influence, in the Israeli government. If their influence was diminished, as it should be, the above incidents would decrease, as the Israeli cops would do something about the rock throwers, and deviants, who assault people. Right now, those extremists are handled with kid gloves.
If it was so clear we would not be in a 2nd deadlock.