NEW YORK (VINnews) — A chareidi Israeli citizen is imprisoned in France for the past three months for reasons unknown to his family. The man, Shmuel Frankel, left Geneva on 7/25/21 on a bus to Marseilles. He was arrested in Marseilles and since then he has been incarcerated without seeing a lawyer and without the authorities contacting his family. His kipah, Tzitzis and Tefillin were taken from him and he is subsisting on fruits and vegetables since he does not receive kosher food. The Israeli embassy has yet to be involved in the matter according to a report by B’Chadrei Chareidim.
Join our WhatsApp groupSubscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
Shmuel’s family say that on 9/23/21 he was tried and found guilty although the charges are not known. He was sentenced to six months in jail and he is currently imprisoned at a prison near Marseilles.
Local Chabad representative Rabbi Immanuel Aryeh Chaim Taubenblatt succeeded in visiting Shmuel on Friday and described him as despondent. Shmuel, who does not know French, categorically denies the charges against him but has no way to assert his rights. His family say that the medicines he requires for diabetes and high blood pressure were also taken from him, leaving him in frail health. On Rosh Hashana, Yom Kippur and Sukkos Shmuel was not able to attend prayers and he was delighted to be able to put on Tefillin on Friday for the first time in three months.
The Israeli foreign ministry said that it is aware of the matter and it is being dealt with by the consular division in Paris.
Please pray for Shmuel Ben Tzivia Esther.
This story has more holes than a donut factory.
There must be more to the story than what’s reported.
Okay everybody, I agree something doesn’t add up here. But still don’t mock the poor guy. I don’t know what he’s really about, but he still deserves the right to an attorney, communication with his family, and his human & religious needs. Even the worst terrorist gets this minimum level of human decency. Why shouldn’t he?
Readers are invited to find even one sentence in this article that might be entirely true.
He pled guilty and denies the charges, but nobody knows what the charges are? The claim that the family does not know what the charges are does not have the ring of truth to it. If the family does not want people to know what the charges are, it is understandable, but just say so.
Something is missing here… aint making any sense
Nothing in this article makes any sense: “he was tried and found guilty although the charges are not known.” and “incarcerated without seeing a lawyer”. Give me a break. France is still a democracy and no one is found guilty without being explained the charges against them . In France even foreigners charged with an offense are entitled to a lawyer and France has the equivalent of Legal Aid for those that can’t afford a lawyer. \
If he wanted the charges against him known, he would have told the interviewer.
Something doesn’t add up here. On the one hand, “charges against him are not known.” On the other – he “categorically denies” them.
??????
Besides, people don’t just get arrested in France and sentenced to 6 months without charges being told them. There must be MUCH more to this story.
Having said that, he is a yid and I wish him released. And I hope it’s tonight.
A very honest yiddishe face. We can be sure he has nothing wrong. and jail is for goyim who have what to be punished about not for him
My SIL a retired US Marshal, when confronted with a chareidi in lockup on Canadian Border, said when he asked for kosher food the supervisor said: If you didn’t commit those crimes you could have had all the kosher food you wanted. I think there is more to the story here, but will not judge till ALL the facts come out.
France is a vicious hotbed of Jew haters. France released an Arab murderer who killed a jewish Holocaust survivor.
Big zadik, when he gets out he can go on a speaking tour, and become a Rebbeh like Rubashkin.
Oy vay, Pidyon Shveeyem, everyone must donate $10,000 to this cause, to save this pure as snow zadik.
Every guy dressed like this is automatically a big zadik, a pious man, why do you think they call the sidecurls on them “pious”, after all?
What was this big Israeli Haredi tzaddik doing traveling alone in Europe in the middle of the summer on a bus, crossing borders from Switzerland to France? What was he carrying with him?