SPRING VALLEY, NEW YORK – (VINnews) In a shocking exchange, the president of the East Ramapo School Board expressed disbelief upon hearing that the district, which had a reported multi-million dollar shortfall, actually had a $31.3 million surplus.
Join our WhatsApp groupSubscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
The revelation came in a November 18th school board meeting, as previously reported on VIN News. Tom Smith, a member of EFPR Group’s professional management team which performed the indepenent audit of East Ramapo’s finances, shared findings that revealed that the district’s expenditures were approximately $30 million below budget as a result of COVID 19 funds and a special grant fund.
Smith’s bombshell had school board president Shimon Rose asking pointedly, “Does this mean we have a $30 million surplus of funds right now?”
Attempting to explain the situation to a clealry uncomfortable-looking Smith, Rose noted that the board had been subjected to dire warnings from district monitors.
“Since last year, I specifically remember our monitors warning us about a dismal future, talking to us about a $30 to $40 million deficit, so much so … that we were talking about not being able to pay teachers because of that,” said Rose.
Rose also noted that the New York State Education Department had repeatedly pressured members of the school board to lobby their elected officials for spin up money in order to keep the district operating, amid calls for additional state oversight.
“We’ve had oversight here for five years, but they are still giving us out incorrect and false budgets,” said Rose. “Why is the state lying to the community and creating false narratives when it’s just not true?”
Responding to Rose, East Ramapo School Superintendent Anthony DiCarlo acknowledged that mistakes have been made, and that the district’s previous administration had not followed best practices in developing the 2024/2025 academic budget. Emphasizing the need for greater transparency, DiCarlo said that the state-appointed monitors were equally upset about to learn about the unexpected surplus, but warned that East Ramapo’s financial troubles were far from over.
“Just because we have this $30 million does not mean this is a silver bullet, and all issues have gone away from East Ramapo,” said DiCarlo. “And you’re going to see this year in the budget process that we’re going to make it more transparent … there’s still a lot of work to do.”

So how are we expected to teach school children proficiency in their academics especially math, if their schoolboard executives can mistakenly confuse a $30,000,000 deficit with a $30,000,000 surplus! After all its only a disparity of $60 million. Like one wise old man was noted to have stated, “a million here, a million there, pretty soon you’re talking about real money!
This whole thing sounds quite foul to me.
It’s Trump’s fault. I’m sure Letitia James will try to find the culprit of this heinous crime.
Where are the machers, shvitzers, askanim, Agudah when we need them?? Taxes were raised based on a lie. The distrcit knew there was a surplus and still went ahead to raise taxes. Why aren’t these crooks being held responsible. Why isn’t the tax increase being repealed. Where is the official statement from AGudah demanding a fix to this??
Maybe Gov Hochul can implement congestion pricing around vizhnitz in Monsey? She can charge “only”$7 a 60% discount from $15. That should solve the school fundiong issue?
I’m Governor Kathy Hochul can clear this all up.
So how are we expected to teach school children proficiency in their academics especially math, if their schoolboard executives can mistakenly confuse a $30,000,000 deficit with a $30,000,000 surplus! After all its only a disparity of $60 million. Like one wise old man was noted to have stated, “a million here, a million there, pretty soon you’re talking about real money!”
This whole thing sounds quite foul to me.
DOGE is working in east ramapo already