Editorial – Queens DA Melinda Katz: A Democrat with Common Sense, Shows Courage and Justice in Subway Self-Defense Case

NEW YORK – (VINnews Editorial) In a time when the line between justice and political expediency can often blur, Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz has reminded us what true justice looks like. By choosing not to press charges against a 69-year-old homeless man who defended himself against violent attackers on the subway, DA Katz has demonstrated courage, fairness, and a commitment to the principle that every individual has the right to protect their life when faced with imminent danger.

The facts of this case are clear and tragic. A vulnerable man, living on the margins of society, found himself the target of an unprovoked and brutal attack by individuals intent on terrorizing him. In those terrifying moments, he did what any reasonable person might do: he fought back to save his life. That one of his attackers died in the altercation is regrettable, but the responsibility for that outcome lies squarely with those who initiated the violence, not with the man defending himself.

District Attorney Katz’s decision reflects an understanding that the justice system must account for context, humanity, and common sense. Prosecuting this man would have sent a chilling message: that self-defense, even in the face of grave danger, could result in criminal charges. Instead, Katz’s choice reinforces the idea that the law exists to protect the innocent and to uphold the right of every person to live without fear of harm.

This case also highlights a broader issue: the plight of the homeless in our cities. Too often, they are treated as invisible or undeserving of compassion. By refusing to criminalize a man who was both a victim and a survivor, Katz has subtly but powerfully affirmed their humanity. It is a reminder that the law must serve everyone, regardless of their social or economic status.

Of course, this decision will not please everyone. There are those who may call for harsher measures in every case involving loss of life, regardless of the circumstances. But true leadership requires the ability to rise above public pressure and to act in accordance with justice and reason. In this instance, Katz has shown that leadership.

We commend DA Melinda Katz for her decision and urge other prosecutors across the country to take note. Justice is not always easy, and it is rarely black and white. But by standing firm in her commitment to fairness and humanity, Katz has set an example of how the justice system can and should operate. In doing so, she has not only upheld the law but also the values that underpin it.

Four men were indicted for allegedly stealing the belongings of a man who was asleep onboard a 7 train in December.

The 69-year-old victim woke up as his bags were being stolen and a fight ensued, leading to the stabbing death of one of the assailants. https://t.co/qU9RL5vA1a pic.twitter.com/UorD1kIG82

— Queens DA Katz (@QueensDAKatz) January 9, 2025