Vatican Official Responds After Israeli Rabbi Criticizes Pope’s Remarks on Iran Conflict

    49

    ROME (VINnews) — A Vatican official has responded to an Israeli rabbi who criticized recent comments by Pope Leo XIV about the conflict between Israel and Iran, according to a report by the The Times of Israel.

    Join our WhatsApp group

    Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


    Rabbi Eliezer Simcha Weisz, a member of Israel’s Chief Rabbinate and its interreligious dialogue committee with the Vatican, wrote to the pope expressing concern that the pope’s public remarks suggested moral equivalence between Israel and those attacking it. Weisz argued that framing the conflict in such terms risks obscuring Israel’s right to self-defense.

    Flavio Pace, a senior official in the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, replied to the letter, thanking the rabbi and stating that relations between the Vatican and the Chief Rabbinate will continue to develop despite disagreements. The response did not directly address the substance of the criticism.

    The exchange comes amid broader tensions surrounding international reactions to the war. The Times of Israel reported the correspondence and said it was unclear whether the reply represented the pope’s official position or a personal response.

    Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


    Connect with VINnews

    Join our WhatsApp group
    49 Comments
    Most Voted
    Newest Oldest
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments
    DJT
    DJT
    16 days ago

    For religion that has caused millennium iof strife and war this is numerous if not sick
    But were was the Vatican while moslems were killing Christian’s in Lebanon or Syria or thru out Africa even today Not a word
    But Isreal that has protected Lebanese, Syrian citizens from being slaughter is criticized and condemned

    Anonymous
    Anonymous
    16 days ago

    The pope should stick to popery !

    Yaakov Miller
    Yaakov Miller
    16 days ago

    the pope has a goyisha kop

    roselle
    roselle
    16 days ago

    Guess it depends on whom the Rabbi addressed in his letter to the pope. I don’t suppose the pope reads everything or responds to it. I think the Rabbi is correct about moral equivalency. And I think that the Pope not responding himself is a slap in the face.

    Daas torah
    Daas torah
    16 days ago

    We should stop commenting on everything the Pope says it gives him credibility

    Nochum
    Nochum
    16 days ago

    I wonder how many times in history the Catholic Church has been proven to be on the wrong side of an issue. It seems to me that it is more often than not.

    David
    David
    16 days ago

    Why have the recent popes been woke/leftists?

    Tali
    Tali
    16 days ago

    Rabbi is CORRECT

    Abba
    Abba
    16 days ago

    Rabbi, please stay of out of this. Let them hash it out without us.

    Bernhard H. Rosenberg
    Bernhard H. Rosenberg
    14 days ago

    Please pray for President Trump, he is being attacked by Islamists, woke right and left, pope, communists, etc. pray for protection and wisdom for President Trump.

    Teshuva
    Teshuva
    15 days ago

    Who cares what popeye says ? His a clown.

    Haimov
    Haimov
    13 days ago

    The Pope did not respond Because He Agrees!!!!

    Ely
    Ely
    16 days ago

    With all due respect, the current pope sounds like a SHMOK

    Yoel
    Yoel
    16 days ago

    It’s becoming a religious r”l rabbi vs the pope,

    Avrohom
    Avrohom
    16 days ago

    It takes a jew to make the Vatican relevant it allways has

    Last edited 16 days ago by Avrohom
    Good gezugt
    Good gezugt
    16 days ago

    The Pope is to Catholics what “Daas Torah” is to the chareidim: infallible. Imagine if one of the so-called Jewish Popes or “gedolei ha’dor” issued a proclamation, and some shmendrick criticizes it, would the Godol respond?!

    HepechHabatim
    HepechHabatim
    16 days ago

    Why should the pope respond to some random mizrachi who is just spouting political talking points