Jerusalem Rabbi Describes ‘Humiliating’ Conditions Of Yeshiva Students In Military Prisons

12

JERUSALEM (VINnews) —  The ongoing arrests and incarcerations of yeshiva students  are continuing to generate public discussion. In an interview on the “Arrest Warrant” program on Kol Hai Radio, Rabbi Asher Abramovitz, one of the senior rabbis of Jerusalem’s yeshiva community, shared a personal account after accompanying a yeshiva student who was arrested, visiting him in military prison, and attending his military court hearings.

Join our WhatsApp group

Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


The rabbi said that although he generally avoids media interviews, he chose to speak publicly because, in his words, “the public simply does not realize what is happening around them.”

He explained that the detainee is an older yeshiva student whose peers have largely married and started families, while he has continued devoting himself to Torah study every day. The moment that affected him most, he said, was seeing his student seated behind a glass partition in the courtroom.

“Instead of sitting in the study hall learning Torah, he was sitting there like a criminal,” the rabbi said.

According to Rabbi Abramovitz, the greatest hardship is not the physical conditions of detention but the ongoing sense of humiliation, including restrictions on speaking with family members, degrading treatment by prison staff, and what he described as a loss of dignity for yeshiva students.

He also described the inmates’ daily routine, which he said includes early wake-up calls, lengthy roll calls, prolonged periods standing before commanding officers, extended confinement in rooms, and various other restrictions.

The rabbi recounted that his student was disciplined after remaining in the synagogue for several extra minutes to continue studying following prayers. As punishment, he said, the student lost his telephone privileges for three days.

He added that the detainees also encountered religious challenges, including issues related to kosher food and the ability to study Torah quietly.

Concluding the interview, Rabbi Abramovitz said the image that will stay with him is seeing his student devastated on the first day of his detention.

“He told me, ‘Rabbi, it’s impossible to survive here,'” he recalled.

The rabbi said that the only way to cope is to remember the spiritual value of a Torah scholar, while also urging the public to empathize with the detainees and recognize that, as he put it, “here is a young man who, instead of sitting in the study hall, was taken away in handcuffs and humiliated.”

Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


Connect with VINnews

Join our WhatsApp group
12 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Simcha
Simcha
1 month ago

If you have no heart for this story, Chareidims condition under arrest for simply belonging in the Chareidi community, than every Chareidi mother would be nuts to send their kids into the army. When there’s a hate problem your completely retarded to send your kids to the people who hate you.
Before this hate problem is defeated, it is completely irresponsible to trust the Israeli army with your Chareidi children!

Last edited 1 month ago by Simcha
lazy-boy
lazy-boy
1 month ago

sad and disheartening .
may HaShem help us…

Educated Archy
Educated Archy
1 month ago

Beats the risk the soilders take of being imprisoned in a dark tunnel in Gaza. Not much sympathy

Cheski Baum
Cheski Baum
1 month ago

Here’s a crazy idea. How about don’t get arrested.

Yvette
Yvette
1 month ago

He was treated like the criminal he is. The law requires him to present himself for enlistment in the IDF. Failure to do so is, prima facie, a criminal offence. Wether non dangerous criminals need to be placed behind glass partitions and handcuffed is another discussion unrelated to whether they are draft dodgers or shoplifters.

Arik
Arik
1 month ago

Can’t do the time , don’t do the crime

Ben Lavi
Ben Lavi
1 month ago

If he was in any other country with a draft, he would be arrested and humiliated way worse.
Israel gives them ability to daven and learn.
Follow the law of the land. If you are drafted, report to the draft board. Nothing more disgusting than a draft dodger.