NEW YORK (VINnews) — William Shakin, a 25-year-old former Israeli soldier from Great Neck, New York, died in New York after struggling with severe psychological distress following his military service in Gaza, according to people who knew him and advocates who had worked with him.
Join our WhatsApp groupSubscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
Shakin immigrated to Israel following the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack and volunteered for military service through the Mahal program for overseas volunteers. He served as a combat soldier in the Golani Brigade’s 13th Battalion and fought in Gaza, where he lost friends and fellow soldiers.
After completing his service, Shakin’s mental health deteriorated significantly, according to people close to him. He was not formally recognized by Israeli authorities as suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, according to Chaim Meizlish, a volunteer with Navigating, a nonprofit that assists lone soldiers dealing with mental health challenges in the United States.
During his military service, Shakin lived at HaBayit Shel Benji, a home that provides housing and support for lone soldiers. Staff members became concerned about his condition after he completed his service and contacted his parents, according to reports.
View this post on Instagram
Shakin eventually returned to the United States. People assisting him continued to provide support before his departure for New York, but advocates say the assistance available through the IDF and Israel’s Defense Ministry ended once he was outside Israel.
Meizlish said Shakin faced particular difficulty obtaining official recognition for combat-related trauma because he would have been required to return to Israel to appear before Defense Ministry committees.
For Shakin, advocates said, that presented a significant obstacle because returning to Israel would have meant leaving the family and support network he had in the United States.
The case has also highlighted broader concerns about support available to Israeli veterans living abroad. Meizlish said Navigating is aware of about 1,200 cases involving Israeli veterans and others dealing with combat-related trauma in the United States, while only two Defense Ministry representatives are assigned to handle such cases, according to his account.
Shakin’s death has also led to a dispute over where he should be buried.
His parents are seeking to have their son brought to Israel for burial in the military cemetery on Mount Herzl. The request has faced opposition from the Defense Ministry, in part because Shakin had not been formally recognized as a combat-trauma victim, according to reports.
The family has criticized the ministry, arguing that Shakin’s service and the psychological consequences he experienced afterward should qualify him for recognition and burial in Israel.
Israeli Minister of Aliyah and Integration Ofir Sofer has pledged to try to help the family bring Shakin’s remains to Israel for burial.
Before his death, Shakin spoke with friends about the trauma he was carrying from his time in Gaza. In one message, he described losing a member of his platoon and the effect it had on him.
“A friend from my platoon was killed,” he wrote. “I’m shaking from trauma … I just lost it.”
Friends and members of his Chabad community remembered Shakin as a warm and generous young man who remained deeply connected to Jewish life.
He regularly attended Shabbat dinners, volunteered to help with community events and readily participated in mitzvot. Friends recalled his willingness to help with everything from setting up tables and chairs to building a sukkah, as well as his enthusiasm for putting on tefillin.
Following his graduation, Shakin chose to leave the United States and serve in Israel, ultimately becoming a combat soldier in one of the IDF’s most prominent infantry brigades.
His death has renewed calls from advocates for stronger systems to assist lone soldiers and other Israeli veterans living outside the country who experience psychological difficulties after combat.
Shakin’s family and friends are seeking to have him laid to rest in Israel, where he served and fought alongside his fellow soldiers.
I’m appalled that Israeli officials aren’t recognizing he deserves to be buried in the country he loved, the people he loved and came to protect. He deserves a purple heart award posthumously. He was a selfless, great person and deserves the hero honors accorded all soldiers. I hope this issue will be resolved in very short order.
Powerful neshama, driven by ahavas Yisrael to protect his people.
Typical of the Israeli attitude. YOU are here to serve US. We do and say what we want and don’t have to explain anything to anybody. Here’s a young man who left the safety of the US and VOLUNTEERED to fight in COMBAT in Gaza. Now they turn their backs on him and his family. If this is what volunteers can expect, what should draftees expect??
He was a hero – Israeli officials need to step up and recognize that.
Where is moshiach ?
Utterly disgusting they won’t even grant him an honorable burial next to his fallen brothers. They should be put on trial for directly causing his death to begin with.
IDF trashed this hero in the dumpster.
Busha v’cherpa.
And you want yeshiva boys to join an army that has no regard for its soldiers. They care more about gazan civilians than their own army. Now we read how soldiers can’t even shoot at terrorists who are armed in Gaza. Everyday israeli soldiers get killed or wounded. You need a ben gevir as prime minister. This government is corrupt from head to toe including the Frum keneset members. Why don’t they step in. Gelt gelt gelt. Had this family win the billion dollar lotto they would bury him anywhere they wanted in israel.
Baruch Dayan haEmes
The trauma is real, and there is extensive support available in Israel after one’s service is completed to help deal with it. Unfortunately, this soldier fell through the cracks – not through anyone’s bad intentions, but due to bureaucratic inflexibility.
He definitely deserves to be buried in Israel – whether in a military or civilian cemetery is to be determined.
May his family know no more Tza’ar.