Report: Israeli Breslov Pilgrim Reportedly Detained at Ukrainian Border, Facing Mobilization To Ukraine Army

13

JERUSALEM (VINnews) — An Israeli man who traveled to Uman for Rosh Hashanah was reportedly detained by Ukrainian authorities while attempting to leave the country and is now believed to be facing mobilization into the Ukrainian military, according to his wife and friends cited by Walla News.

Join our WhatsApp group

Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


Yonatan Karlinsky Mashak, 49, a married resident of Beitar Illit who studies at a yeshiva, was stopped Wednesday afternoon at the Orlivka-Isaccea border crossing between southern Ukraine and Romania. The international crossing operates by ferry across the Danube River.

Karlinsky, who was born in Ukraine when it was part of the Soviet Union and immigrated to Israel about 14 years ago, had traveled to Uman for the annual Rosh Hashanah pilgrimage. Tens of thousands of Breslov Hasidim traveled to the Ukrainian city this year for the holiday.

He was traveling on a bus operated by Derech Tzadikim, according to a friend who was traveling with him. Karlinsky was carrying an Israeli passport that lists the Soviet Union as his place of birth. However, the friend said Ukrainian border officials apparently realized that Karlinsky also held Ukrainian citizenship after hearing him speak Ukrainian. The officials removed him from the bus for further questioning. His friends have not seen or heard from him since.

Shortly after being detained, Karlinsky managed to send an email reporting what had happened. He also attempted to call his wife twice. When she later tried to return the calls, however, she reached only a voicemail message in Ukrainian.

Nathan, a Jerusalem friend who spoke about the case, said the family was subsequently informed that Karlinsky had been transferred to the Odessa area for military mobilization.

“He has traveled to Uman for years, including since the beginning of the war, and he was never detained,” Nathan said. “He apparently thought that because he had Israeli citizenship, he would not have a problem in Ukraine.”

Karlinsky’s wife, Odel, told Israeli media that she was extremely distressed by the situation. She said she initially did not realize that anything was wrong because she had missed the two calls from her husband shortly after his detention.

“I never imagined that they had detained him,” she said. “He traveled as he does every year and never thought for a moment that this could happen.”

According to information available to the family, Karlinsky is being held at a military base near Odesa as authorities begin the process of mobilizing him.

“As long as he is medically fit, as far as they are concerned he is fit,” Odel said. “They don’t release people from the army until the age of 60. At the moment, everything is up in the air. We still don’t know exactly what will happen or how we can help him.”

The case highlights the potential difficulties facing Ukrainian citizens who also hold foreign citizenship. Ukraine has maintained broad wartime mobilization rules for male citizens of military age, and Ukrainian citizenship can remain legally significant even when a person has lived abroad for many years.

For Karlinsky’s family, however, the situation is particularly complicated because he has lived in Israel for more than a decade and is an observant Jew studying at a yeshiva. His wife and friends expressed concern that military service would make it extremely difficult for him to maintain his religious lifestyle, including access to kosher food and the ability to observe Jewish religious requirements.

“It is not simple for me at all. It is very difficult,” Odel said. “But with God’s help, I hope that salvation will come and everything will end.”

She said she is in contact with Israel’s Foreign Ministry and has asked the government for urgent assistance. “I believe the consulate and embassy will try to do everything to bring him home,” she said. “But they explained to me gently that anything involving Ukrainian law is under their authority. They told me that what happened was legal — and that is the problem.”

She stressed that she considers her husband’s Israeli identity and life in Israel central to the case. “He has lived in Israel for more than 14 years. He is Jewish, an Israeli citizen, he has a home here and a life here. He is not a number. Everything must be done to bring him home,” she said.

The Israeli Foreign Ministry had not issued a public response to the case at the time of publication.

The detention comes as thousands of Breslov Hasidim return from Uman following the Rosh Hashanah pilgrimage. The annual journey has continued despite Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, although pilgrims have faced heightened security, travel and border restrictions since the war began.

 

Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


Connect with VINnews

Join our WhatsApp group
13 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
netzach
netzach
1 month ago

Praying that he makes it back home.

I hope people realize it’s NOT MAALIN BAKODESH when you leave E”Y to Chmelnitzki-land and stop this insanity especially b’shaas sakanas milchama. Even Rav Nacchman ZY”A would agree IT’S A YERIDAH NOT AN ALIYAH.

Simple
Simple
1 month ago

As I get to hear more and more troubles of Uman ; the answer is ; do Not go to Uman ; especially over Rosh Hashanah..

Nesanel
Nesanel
1 month ago

So instead of fighting for Klal Yisroel, he’ll RL be fighting for the Ukranians. Very sad.

lazy-boy
lazy-boy
1 month ago

I hope he is able to get out of this mess…..

Yvette
Yvette
1 month ago

So it is not just the Zionist infidels who want all their citizens to share the burden

Last edited 1 month ago by Yvette
DSC
DSC
1 month ago

Pagan nonsense

Yitzchok
Yitzchok
1 month ago

As a supporter of breslover chasidim and hope and pray he gets out of this terrible situation to the many others who have gotten arrested weather in isreal or overseas why put yourself s in danger I think it’s blind stupidity

Just saying
Just saying
1 month ago

May Hashem protect him and send him back to his family. Perhaps, once he gets back, he will draft to the IDF as a way of thanking Hashem for his release