Brooklyn, NY – At Misaskim, unexpected and sad realities of life are unfortunately a daily occurrence. But last week, Misaskim was presented with an even more perplexing question than usual: what to do with a bar of soap that many Holocaust survivors believe contains human remains? This rare bar of soap, engraved with the letters RIF, was recently discovered by the Mermelstein family while cleaning up the apartment of their aging uncle, Yosef Weinberger.
Join our WhatsApp groupSubscribe to our Daily Roundup Email
Weinberger was a young adolescent who survived during the Holocaust by hiding in bunkers. Of a family of 13, only Yosef and 3 other siblings survived. However, it wasn’t only the chilling memories of his youth that shadowed Yosef each day. Tucked away in a faded green suitcase, he kept various items that were a testament to the inferno he survived. Among these objects was a tattered She’eris Hapleitah Siddur, books from the war era, legal immigration documents, and various wartime letters. Mr. Meremelstein, Yosef’s nephew, was startled when he also discovered a little package carefully wrapped in brown paper that contained a small, brownish, numbered bar of RIF soap.
Many Holocaust survivors believe that the RIF soap was made from the fat of Jewish victims during the Holocaust R’L. They have been told that RIF is the acronym for Reines Juden Fett. In fact, Nuremburg Trial judges, after accepting the testimony of a Polish national, Sigmund Mazur, ruled that the soap does indeed contain human remains,. Mazur told the judges that during the war he had worked as a laboratory assistant for Rudolf Spanner, a German professor, at the Gdansk Anatomical Institute. Mazur related that he had been involved in the production of soap from human fat.
In 2006, Poland’s “IPN” (Poland’s National Remembrance Institute) announced that it had completed an inquiry that confirmed that the soap had been rendered from human fat. Professor Andrzej Stolyhwo, who conducted the study for the IPN, obtained a sample of the soap that was presented at the Nuremberg trials and tested its contents. Stolyhwo declared that his study proves that the soap was made between 1945 and 1946 under the direction of Professor Spanner.
However, today it is universally accepted by historians and Holocaust experts that only a small amount of soap was produced by Spanner and that the soap was never mass produced. They explain that RIF stands for Reichsstelle Fur Industrielle Fettversorgung (Reich Center for Industrial Fat Provisioning). Yad V’shem, The Simon Wiesenthal Center, and other prestigious Holocaust museums all agree that since no hard evidence was ever uncovered that the soap was produced from human victims, it was most likely a cruel rumor that the Nazis spread in order to psychologically torture Jewish inmates.
Victims in the concentration camps were taunted by the SS and told that they would soon be turned into soap. Survivors, who had witnessed unspeakable horrors, firmly believed this to be true. Immediately after the war, public levayas were held in Austria, France, Germany, Romania, and Israel during which bars of RIF soap were buried. Metzeivos were erected at the burial sites memorializing those who were murdered by the Nazis and who had never received a proper burial.
Misaskim is currently consulting with its rabbinical authority to determine the appropriate way of treating the RIF soap, and whether it needs to be buried. It is Misaski’s sincerest hope — whatever the outcome — that this incident should serve to be m’kadeish shem Shamayim all those who perished in the Holocaust and who were never brought to kvuras Yisroel.
Do they not realize that these days, the bar of soap can in fact be tested for human remains? I would think that may be the first step. Although – I am not sure if there is a different outcome if the soap would be made of only fat or if it was made from the actual remains (including fat) of a murdered human. It’s a sad reality to have to deal with these things even in 2011 and beyond….
I agree with #1 , it can & should be tested for its contents.
Should Misaskim have a problem what to do with it, there are pleanty of other organizations that have plots & resources to bury it.
How does RIF stand for reines Juden fett?
In any case, this matter has already been addressed and it has been clearly established that no soap was ever produced on an industrial scale from human remains. Therefore it would be a good idea not to publicly spread this falsehood. Holocaust deniers keep pointing to the fact that Jews keep repeating lies as proof that the entire holocaust never happened.
Test the soap, end of story.
Yad Vashem and others already saw DNA testing of Soviet-provided human soap and found it to be fake. This is an old story that was rejected in the 1960s by Yad Vashem and others.
don’t understand why they have to ask a SHAILA,why not just bury it?
this story has a lot of holes
dna testing isn’t free. in fact it’s quite pricey.
Reines Juden Fett would be RJF, not RIF, no?
( Reichstelle für Industrialle Fettversorgung – German fats industry)
I feel sick, this is so distressing. Why would this poor man keep the soap? He must have been such a tormented soul. BD”E.
either way cant this soap be added in when a person is buried?
Must do a DNA testing and let the world see the barbarisim of human beings.