WATCH: Here’s what the Gedolim told Knesset Members About the Hostage Trade (VIN EXCLUISVE)

64

BNEI BRAK (VIN Podcast) — Charedi journalist Yanki Farber revealed that the Charedi MK’s consulted with several Gedolim, prior to voting in favor of the hostage trade.

Join our WhatsApp group

Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


He says that the Rabbonim who were consulted by Knesset Members from Shas and UTJ include Rav Moshe Hillel Hirsch shlit”a, Rav Dov Landau shlit”a, and Rav Yitzchak Yosef shlit”a.

WATCH THE CLIP:

In addition, Yanki revealed new details and provided analysis about the Hamas hostage trade.

He said that sadly, Hamas may not be aware of the location and condition of many of the hostages, and they have not been open with Israel about these details. He also discussed the risk of a 5-day cease-fire, and whether it will allow Hamas to regroup and become more dangerous.

And Yanki discussed the fate of PM Netanyahu, as well as the heads of security, with whom the Israeli public is disenchanted, due to their major intelligence failure that was exposed on October 7.

WATCH FULL INTERVIEW BELOW:



Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


Connect with VINnews

Join our WhatsApp group


64 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Resident
Resident
2 months ago

Isn’t it a vadai that incentivizes more people to get captured?

Gedolim ?
Gedolim ?
2 months ago

We are currently attacking them so it is difficult to regroup and rearm. They will use the ceasefire to prepare and better their positions.
They will use the no spying clause to move the other hostages making it more difficult to free them
They have the option to extend our attack us as they are fit giving them the ER look element of surprise. They used that when the kidnapped hadar goldin during a ceasefire 10 years ago

Judge.Dayan
Judge.Dayan
2 months ago

Everybody knows the hostage deal is terrible. But I’m guessing there are more factors involved that the public doesn’t know. for example, Israel was threatened by the Biden administration, if they don’t take the deal, the U.S. will turn on Israel and completely stop support. With that factor, I can understand that the Gedolim paskened, there is no choice.

Aguttenshabbos
Aguttenshabbos
2 months ago

See ladies and gentlemen? I wasn’t wrong about me wondering at an earlier story about the trade, whether they went to seek advice from Daas Torah. Even the our non-religious brethren get it.

Gedolim ?
Gedolim ?
2 months ago

There were Gedolim that supported the Disengagement from Gaza and Oslo.

In fact Shas supported Oslo and UTJ supported Sharon throughout the disengagement siting these same “Gedolim”.

anonymous
anonymous
2 months ago

What do you think about this issue? Not the Gedolim. Just you.

Jj friedman
Jj friedman
2 months ago

From the Jerusalem Post “ Israel rejects Hamas ceasefire demand to leave Gaza’s Shifa – report”. Before the ceasefire even started we the Hamas animals demand and evacuation and f Hifa hospital. Israel not an inch.