OPINION: Israel acts as an outsourced army for the United States for pennies

17

(DUVI HONIG / VINnews) — It is time to clarify the facts surrounding Israel’s relationship with the United States as the nation approaches its 2024 elections. Israel has faced criticism from both the liberal left and some presidential hopefuls on the right, with calls to cease American aid due to concerns about the burden on taxpayers.

Join our WhatsApp group

Subscribe to our Daily Roundup Email


However, it is important to recognize that Israel provides invaluable services to the US in the Middle East at a fraction of their true value.

For an annual fee of $3 billion, Israel effectively acts as an outsourced army for the United States for pennies, working tirelessly to safeguard American interests in a volatile region. Furthermore, Israel is the sole recipient of US funding that commits to reinvesting those dollars in the US economy, specifically supporting American businesses. The research and development shared by Israel with US companies is priceless and contributes more to the US economy than the $3 billion provided in aid.

In essence, the US is not simply giving funds to Israel to maintain in its own economy. Instead, these funds are being recycled back into the US economy, generating a considerably higher return on investment than any business venture worldwide. The intelligence provided by Israel has proven vital in preventing numerous terrorist attacks on the West and its allies, thus upholding global security and stability. Without Israel’s unwavering commitment to protection, the Middle East would be susceptible to chaos and terrorism.

When comparing this relatively small sum to the exorbitant amounts invested in other countries like Afghanistan, it becomes apparent that Israel’s contributions represent unparalleled value and cost-effectiveness. The billions of dollars’ worth of ammunition abandoned in Afghanistan only served to bolster America’s enemies and undermine its own interests. In contrast, Israel’s intelligence, services, and advanced weaponry have proven instrumental in safeguarding American lives and interests.

It is incorrect to view Israel as a beneficiary of American aid. Instead, Israel should be seen as a service provider offering unmatched expertise, intelligence, and technology to the US. The country leads in the creation of state-of-the-art ammunition and artillery, which enhances the safety of Americans both domestically and internationally. Moreover, Israel’s technological advancements, such as the Iron Dome, not only protect its own citizens but also benefit the United States and its military.

Those who argue that Israel is reliant on American support fail to grasp the immeasurable value it brings to the table. Establishing US troops and an intelligence network in the Middle East would cost American taxpayers an astronomical amount, estimated at tens of billions of dollars annually. Moreover, such an endeavor would significantly compromise efficiency and effectiveness.

Israel’s contributions extend well beyond financial assistance; their impact on lives saved, thwarting of terrorist activities, and overall stability and security is incalculable. It is essential to recognize the immense value that Israel’s assistance provides and to reject those who belittle and misunderstand this relationship.

The United States owes Israel a debt of gratitude for its steadfast commitment to preserving America’s security, democracy, and the well-being of its people. Describing the $3 billion as aid distorts the reality; it is instead an investment, a service fee, and only a fraction of the value Israel provides in return. It is high time to acknowledge and appreciate the immeasurable contributions Israel makes to the United States and the world.

Additionally, the comparison can be drawn with America’s investment in Afghanistan, which has yielded little success. Billions of dollars’ worth of ammunition were left behind and fell into the hands of the Taliban, inadvertently aiding America’s enemies. This represents a significant loss of resources, unlike the allocation to Israel, which offers substantial returns on investment.

We must not forget that Israel stands at the forefront of creating state-of-the-art ammunition and artillery, thereby enhancing the safety of American soldiers both domestically and internationally. Furthermore, Israel’s technological advancements, shared with the US, play a vital role in safeguarding civilians and military personnel.

If the US were to independently handle its troops and intelligence in the Middle East, costs would skyrocket to tens of billions of dollars annually while diminishing efficiency. Israel provides a more cost-effective and efficient solution, fighting battles on America’s behalf and protecting it from the threat of terrorism.

Moreover, Israel’s efforts have long-lasting effects on global security. For instance, their destruction of Iraq’s nuclear reactor ensured West security for 20 years. Had Iraq possessed nuclear weapons during America’s intervention, the loss of life and destruction would have been catastrophic.

Therefore, it is crucial to recognize Israel’s vital role as America’s outsourced army and its contribution to preserving America, democracy, and the entire Western world’s safety. Individuals criticizing Israel for receiving American aid must understand that this is a mutually beneficial relationship, with Israel providing critical services and tremendous value in return. It is not a gift but rather an expense and vital service that serves American interests. Together, let us rally to support and express gratitude towards Israel for its unwavering commitment to our collective security.

Duvi Honig is Founder and CEO of the Orthodox Jewish Chamber Of Commerce (www.OjChamber.com), a global umbrella of businesses of all sizes, bridging the highest echelons of the business and governmental worlds together, stimulating economic opportunity and positively affecting public policy around the world. Duvi unites and empowers people of all backgrounds, and influences public policy at the local, state, federal and international levels. His work was recognized by both President Obama and President Trump and, in 2016, he was honored by a bipartisan group of Senators in the Capitol. The Chambers leadership was recognized most recently by Israel’s D Prime Minister, Israeli Ministers and Members of the Knesset for its advocacy and support on behalf of Israel and the global economy.

To contact the author email [email protected]

THE VIEWS EXPRESSED DO NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THOSE OF VIN NEWS


Listen to the VINnews podcast on:

iTunes | Spotify | Google Podcasts | Stitcher | Podbean | Amazon

Follow VINnews for Breaking News Updates


Connect with VINnews

Join our WhatsApp group


17 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lgb
Lgb
8 months ago

Israel is clearly too tied into the US. It’s not healthy for any country to be so dependent on another.

Once Was
Once Was
8 months ago

It’s before the Yomim Noraim. Stop your hate and antique propaganda

Just a thought
Just a thought
8 months ago

So you believe everything that happens to jews or Israel is by the decision of the goyim not by הקב”ה You must be a כופר באלוקי ממעל.

Captain obvious
Captain obvious
8 months ago

You can make the case that Israel should still be receiving aid from the U.S. without exaggerating Israel’s importance. It’s not like Israeli soldiers go on missions with U.S. soldiers in Syria or Iraq (and I’m not arguing that they should.)

George S. Patton
George S. Patton
8 months ago

Another voice from the “peanut gallery”.

All of a sudden, King Duvi of Lakewood is an expert on military logistics. I guess that is because so many of his Haredi followers serve or have served in the American military and/or the IDF.

Aguttenshabbos
Aguttenshabbos
8 months ago

Wow. That headline says it all. Agreed!!

Phineas
Phineas
8 months ago

That’s the case with almost any nation chochom

triumphinwhitehouse
triumphinwhitehouse
8 months ago

not exactly true as that would require IDF to fight Americas wars which it avoided in Iraq and Afghanistan

ashi
ashi
8 months ago

no chiddush here
this is something that has been said for the longest time by middle east experts.
the solution might be for Israel to convince America that the funds should be appropriated differently maybe as a defense bill or strategic investment, this way no fringe congressmen can advocate for the discontinuation of aid to Israel.

Charlie Hall
Charlie Hall
8 months ago

anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism

Phineas
Phineas
8 months ago

Some things are better left unsaid and he acts like Israel is doing it for America’s sake.